by Robertson Davies
Dunstan's childhood takes place in Canada, but he travels to Europe for the war, teaching, and searching for saints later in his life. The book goes from his childhood in the early 1900s to his later life. The letter was written in 1970.
Dunstable Ramsay is writing the whole book in the form of a letter defending his identity to the headmaster.
Mrs. Ramsay's main relationship with Dunstan is one of power. She wants a "dear own laddie," and breaks down and beats him when he's getting too far away.
Mary Dempster is Dunstan's "fool saint." He sees his life as tied around her.
Amasa Dempster is Mrs. Dempster's husband. Dunstan sees him as weak. He often falls to his knees in loud, occasionally insulting, prayer.
Paul Dempster, or Magnus Eisengrim, takes on the role of the magician. He runs away from home and joins a traveling circus.
Boy Stanton, named Percy in childhood, is Dunstan's "lifelong friend and enemy." He's high on the social, as well as economic, ladder.
Leola is Boy's wife. She can't progress as far as Boy, and partly because of that, has self esteem issues.
Liesl is incredibly perceptive. She gives Dunstan awareness of his own role, functioning as a devil.
- Boy throws a snow ball at Dunstan, and as he has just stepped in front of Mr. and Mrs. Dempster, it hits Mrs. Dempster, sending her into early labor
- Dunstan (D from now on) grows up helping at the Dempsters' house at his mother's request
- he has a crush on Leola, and goes out with her when her boy friend, Boy, is in officer's training
- Mrs. Dempster sleeps with a tramp, and is labeled a whore (later, Dunstan sees this as her 1st miracle)
- D runs and fetches Mrs. Dempster when his brother, William, seems dead. She brings William back to life. (looking back, D sees this as her 2nd miracle)
- leaves for the army when he and his mom become even farther apart
- he finishes a mission to clear out a machine gun nest, but is ashamed- there was no glory in it
- he lost his leg in the incident, and saw a Madonna statue that looks like Mrs. Dempster as he passes out (the third miracle)
- D comes to in the care of a nurse, Diana
- he goes out with her, but doesn't want to marry her- she's too motherly, and he wants to go search for statues. Still, she renames him "Dunstan" as opposed to "Dunstable"
- he visits his hometown for a hero's welcome, then is off to university
- the tramp (Surgeoner) talks at the school, and D visits him, recognizing him. Surgeoner describes how sleeping with Mrs. Dempster reformed him, her first miracle
- D is a saint enthusist, and meets Paul's magician groups- twice
- he visits Mrs. D, eventually taking responsibility over her care once her relative dies. He puts her in a mental health asylum.
- Leola and Boy's marriage falls apart. Leola can't be enough for him. She attempts suicide, fails, then falls sick and dies (with a questionable open window on a chilly day involved)
- D meets Eisengrim (Paul) and Liesl the second time he meets Paul's group
- Mrs. Dempster dies
- Both Paul and Boy go looking for D, and the two end up meeting. D explains the snowball in their past, and Paul kills Boy.
Tone- distant and factual as it's told later in his life, when the feelings have been rounded. It's introspective.
Imagery- little because of the tone
symbols:
the brazen head- Liesl's role as a character with wisdom (a director, God, or devil)
the reapperance of the stone- Dunstan as 5th business, inevitably wraps things up
many biblical allusions- Paul as Jesus (he's born in early winter of Mary, but also, card player and magician- anti christ, perhaps? could make the argument)
"But if I may say so, Dunny, I think you've let the thing build up into something it never was."
As the whole novel shows how much of his life Dunstan has based on the snowball incident, it's startling to hear this voiced. It's a sharp contrast. The last time that the two spoke of the event, Boy denied it, and by now he was able to forget. Dunstan's and Boy's reactions say a lot about their characters. Boy is ever moving forward, while Dunstan broods.
"Who are you? Where do you fit into poetry and myth? Do you know who I think you are, Ramsay? I think you are fifth business."
Liesl identifies his role as Fifth Business. He's that small yet necessary plot piece who brings everything together.
It's a warning against passivity, which hurts self identity and expression.
- Dunstan is always filling others' roles for him
- ^ his quiet, agreeable self for Boy
- ^ a hero for Diana
- even his denial of Diana to search for saints leads to it- it's his obsession with roles and his ideal self